Carini Brick Oven Cafe | Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Lords Valley

Overview

Nestled in the heart of Lords Valley, Pennsylvania, Carini Brick Oven Cafe is a welcoming destination for lovers of authentic Italian fare and artisan coffee. Located conveniently at 680 PA-739, this charming restaurant crafts a genuine brick oven experience, celebrated for its naturally leavened sourdough pizzas and fresh, thoughtfully prepared dishes.

The menu is a refined selection with something for everyone, from savory classics like Brooklyn-style pizza and Chicken Marsala to innovative salads bursting with seasonal ingredients. The Apple Walnut Chicken salad, with its housemade candied walnuts and fresh greens, and the Burrata & Prosciutto combination exemplify the cafe’s commitment to quality and balance. For seafood enthusiasts, the Citrus Basil Salmon special is notable, showcasing a vibrant and well-executed main course.

Carini’s atmosphere strikes a pleasing balance between cozy and spacious, making it an ideal stop for families, couples, or solo diners. The large parking area adds convenience, while the interior boasts clean, inviting decor with friendly service that has earned notable praise from visitors. Whether you're enjoying a leisurely lunch or an evening meal, the ambiance supports a relaxed dining experience.

The brick oven pizzas are the true stars here—thin-crusted, with fresh toppings and an expertly blistered crust that evokes Italy’s authentic pizzerias. Customers appreciate the freshness of the ingredients and the care in each pie’s preparation. Complementing the hearty meals are sides like house-breaded calamari and truffle fries, alongside a Salumi Board that pairs perfectly with their full bar and thoughtful beer selection.

On the beverage front, Carini shines with an in-house coffee and gelato program that elevates the usual cafe offerings. The Freddo Matcha Latte, crafted with cold foam, appeals to those seeking non-dairy options and flavorful alternatives to coffee. Homemade gelato adds a sweet finish to any meal, reflecting the cafe’s focus on fresh, handcrafted quality.

What stands out most is how Carini Brick Oven Cafe merges authentic Italian culinary tradition with a warm, community-focused environment. Whether you're passing through on a road trip or looking for a neighborhood spot with consistently good food and drinks, this venue offers a dependable and delightful experience. With attentive staff, a diverse menu, and a comfortable setting, it’s easy to see why many consider Carini a must-stop in Lords Valley.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Lunch

Dinner

Solo dining

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Comfort food

Quick bite

Small plates

Spirits

Wine

Atmosphere

Casual

Cosy

Quiet

What Customers Say

Jennys Love

Dec 11,2025

5/5

What a great little restaurant, we're from out of town. The pizza had fresh toppings and seasonings the crust was cooked perfectly a small was perfect size for me and my husband. They have have a full bar and great beer list. Our waitress recommended a beer and she was spot on. A must stop

BB Lynn

Dec 11,2025

4/5

Food was decent but overpriced in my honest opinion. Pizza was made fresh and from scratch. Brick oven, authentic Italian pizza. The pizza is what I’d imagine I’d get if I went to Italy. Wasn’t over the top fancy but it was good and you can tell it was fresh ingredients. Dough is homemade sourdough and thin crust but that’s by design and it was quite tasty. Fried calamari actually didn’t taste premade. Appeared to be breaded and fried at the restaurant and not premade prebought. They claim the Gelato is homemade on site as well. That was good as well. Atmosphere and service was great. Not busy at all on a Friday night. Only 5 of us in the whole restaurant…. Not sure what to make of that honestly. All food pictured cost $50. We got water.

Kevin Ng

Dec 11,2025

4/5

We had a pleasant lunch experience there this afternoon. Although we had to wait a little while, it was worth it in the end. The parking lot is massive, which is very convenient. The food was delicious, and there's something for everyone on the menu. It's a great place for families since all ages are welcome.

Luke Hensel

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Food and service are top quality. Naturally leavened pizza crust. Delicious entrees- my eggplant was sliced and cooked perfectly. Gelato and coffee is made in house - delicious.

Anna Arnesen

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Travelling from Upstate NY to family in PA for the first time. I was super hungry and we also wanted fun drinks (taking a break from coffee, so matcha or chai). We also try to go to small businesses whenever possible. Found Carini's on our route and they had lattes, matcha, pizza, and Italian sandwiches! They had non-dairy milk options too. I got the Freddo Matcha Latte (Iced with Cold Foam I think) & it was soooo good, on the expensive side, but no more expensive than most of the places we go these days. And the sandwiches, oh man. I think the bread we got was fresh out of the oven. The bread was so warm, fluffy, and delicious. Some of the best sandwich bread I've had. I got the Chicken Parm Sandwich & my husband got the pesto sausage & peppers one. Both were fresh, hot, & delicious. AND it all came out within 10 min, since we were taking it to-go. Cute inside too with friendly staff & clean bathrooms. This will probably be a go-to stop for us.

Joshua Anderson

Dec 11,2025

5/5

For drinks, we got an iced cappuccino and an iced mocha. For food, we got a Mediterranean shrimp salad and a sausage and green pepper pizza, well done. The salad was excellent, and the NY style pizza was on point. Foldable with a good crunch on the dough. Everything we ate was excellent, the service was great, and we enjoyed the ambiance.

Vincent haas

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Sort of stumbled on this place, but what a find! If it had nothing more than a great beer list (several Trappist beers!), we’d have loved it. But the Brooklyn pizza was exceptional…thin crust baked crispy, excellent sauce, and mozzarella that tastes like it was just made that morning. The young lady who took care of us was pleasant and efficient (she seemed to be working alone but was totally on top of her game). Can you get a cheaper pizza or meal somewhere else? Sure. But this was a quality experience and worth every penny. We’re looking forward to going back.